December 17, 2018

Love Triangles That Inspired ‘One Day In December’

Two’s company, three’s a crowd—unless in fiction, when it’s a recipe for page-turning, emotional gold dust.

Story By: Josie Silver

Love Triangles That Inspired ‘One Day In December’

Two’s company, three’s a crowd—unless in fiction, when it’s a recipe for page-turning, emotional gold dust. Story By: Josie Silver

Two’s company, three’s a crowd—unless in fiction, when it’s a recipe for page-turning, emotional gold dust. It’s a theme returned to over and again in literature, because nothing else offers quite the same level of conflict, tension or heart-in-the-mouth angst as a good old love triangle.

Obvious examples jump out from the classics; Heathcliff, Catherine & Edgar’s bleak, tempestuous life on the wilderness of the Yorkshire moors in Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights, and in Lady Chatterley’s Lover, D.H. Lawrence gave us Lady Constance, Sir Clifford & their gardener, Mellors. Considered too racy in its day, it’s actually a tender study of a marriage in crisis.

Love triangles haven’t fallen out of fashion in contemporary novels, either. I can’t think of Helen Fielding’s Bridget Jones’s Diary without immediately thinking of Mark Darcy and Daniel Cleaver, too. There are few books in the world I love more than Helen Fielding’s “Bridget Jones” novels; I only have to open the pages and I’m fully invested in all of the characters.

For me, its triumph lies in the fact that although Daniel is a complete rogue, he’s lovable and charming with it—we get a sense that he genuinely does harbor feelings for Bridget. Their relationship would have been a complete disaster long-term, of course, but the fact that we can’t help but empathize and love Daniel a little makes the triangle believable. In contrast, Mark Darcy is so terribly clipped and uptight, lacking any of Daniel’s charisma and easy wit; it takes a while to warm to him as the stoic, loyal, quieter hero of the piece.

“I thought about all of these things when it came to writing ‘One Day in December.'”

Stephenie Meyer’s Twilight trilogy is a great example of a love triangle with three almost equal sides. As readers, we recognize that both Edward and Jacob have the potential to be Bella’s forever love. For the record, I will always be #TeamJacob. And that is probably the most compelling thing of all about love triangles in fiction; we know that the crunch point has to come, and readers get to nail our hopes to the flag on which way we want it to go. It’s an unpopular opinion, but I still think Bella should have chosen Jacob!

I thought about all of these things when it came to writing One Day in December. I’ve always believed love triangles are at their most interesting when there are no obvious villains or heroes. I wanted to acknowledge that real life IS often messy and complicated, and that sometimes people do the wrong thing with the best of intentions.

The story spans a ten-year period, and over the course of the book there are actually two love triangles in play; the more traditionally romantic one between Laurie, Oscar and Jack, and the non-romantic, but surprisingly complex one between Laurie, Jack and her best friend, Sarah. Early on in the book Laurie chooses not to reveal that Sarah’s new boyfriend, Jack, is the guy whom she fell hopelessly in love at first sight with the year before, thereby placing a lie at the center of their friendship. It’s a selfless decision made out of love and loyalty, and even though it inevitably comes back to bite her, I don’t think Laurie would make different choices if she had the chance to do it again. There’s a pivotal scene where Laurie herself acknowledges the unique nature of this central trio and how the feelings between them have evolved over the years and entwined them forever: I remember the first day I met Sarah, and the first time I saw Jack, and how very tangled and complicated our lives have become over the years. We are a triangle, but our sides have kept changing length. Nothing has ever been quite equal. Perhaps it’s time to learn how to stand on our own, rather than lean on each other.

Many readers have said that the nuanced friendship between Laurie and Sarah is their favorite “love story” in the book, and I admit, I do love the idea that a friendship can have just as profound an impact on one’s life as a great romantic love.

Nothing better than starting the day with Isola ☀️

📷: @kenzienoelle.reads
#ad You aren’t dreaming! We are adding another chapter to one of your favorite books.

Reese’s Book Club and @IKEAUSA have teamed up to extend the tale of one of our picks, How To End A Love Story by @yulin.kuang. The new chapter will be the perfect bedtime story, and we can’t wait for you to hear it.

Visit our link in bio to shop Yulin’s favorite sleep essentials and check back soon for her extended story. We might just have another one coming…
"Working little by little, day by day, you will get to the end of your journey." 

@AllegraGoodmanWriter sharing incredible advice for writer's and people alike. Thank you for being our February Pick 💙
GIVEAWAY: Find out the significance of the letter by entering to win a copy of Famous Last Words by @gillianmauthor. Hint: It's in the first chapter 😉

To ENTER:
1. Like this post 💙
2. Follow @reesesbookclub 🤝
3. Tag a friend! 📖

Giveaway ends 03/10/25 at 11:59 PT. 10 winners will be notified by DM from @reesesbookclub. No purchase necessary. U.S. only.
Everyone needs a Damienne in their life 💙

Check the link in our bio to start reading Isola.
Our Sunday plan: soaking up sunshine with a great book ☀️📖
And just like that, the highly-requested full library reveal! 😍 Isn't she stunning?

📷: @theintrovertedition
Just the essentials 🥰

📷: @readyourworriesaway
#ad We love a good book as part of our nightly wind down routine!

Thanks to @IKEAUSA we’ll be revisiting some of our favorite books, like Twelfth Knight by @afarolfollmuth, and sharing a brand-new bonus chapter coming soon! Visit our link in bio to shop her favorite IKEA sleep essentials.
“It’s not just that he’s a villain, but that he represents a man of his time.” Author @allegragoodmanwriter shares what makes Roberval such a terrifying antagonist in Isola.
This error message is only visible to WordPress admins
There has been a problem with your Instagram Feed.