May 28, 2024

Writing The Unlikeable Female Narrator

Alexene Farol Follmuth on writing Twelfth Knight, our Summer YA Reese’s Book Club Pick

Writing The Unlikeable Female Narrator

Alexene Farol Follmuth on writing Twelfth Knight, our Summer YA Reese's Book Club Pick

Dear Reader,

It was never my intention to write a second young adult rom-com after my first, My Mechanical Romance, because as someone primarily focused on the adult speculative space under my pseudonym, Olivie Blake (and as someone who was probably/definitely getting an A in therapy), I’d already healed my inner child. What further need could I possibly have to probe any further into the realm of coming-of-age?

Well, except that the teenage protagonist of my first YA novel was very likable, almost diabolically so, whereas I, at her age… wasn’t. (I’ve been called Tracy Flick more than once in my life, so do with that what you will.) My Mechanical Romance’s Bel lacked not only my morbid cynicism and general disillusionment, but also—perhaps connectedly—my ambitions, my passions, and my rage.

As a teenager, I was what they call an “unlikable female character”—the kind of narrator that would prompt half of Goodreads to say, but why is she so mad? And yes, the answer was partly societal—after all, how many of us can instantly summon that low-boiling fury over being told to smile more, gritting niceties over and over through constant microaggressions that are highly gendered, and very often, identity-specific, too?—but it was also very personal. The difficulty I had constantly trying to prove my competency, the fatigue over always having to defend my hobbies and interests, all of that ultimately made me sharper-edged, unwilling to trust in the sincerity of others. For a significant portion of my life, I was unable to believe that my real self could ever be accepted, much less loved.

Then, as an adult watching the sociopolitical climate worsen—as I watched Christine Blasey Ford publicly relive the violence of her past with unshakable calm; as the #MeToo movement gave way to the comeback tour of “canceled” but unsilenceable men; as massive franchises attempted to diversify who belonged in their stories only to sacrifice their actors of color to the lawlessness of mob rule; as communities of fandom and gaming increasingly drove away marginalized creators—I started asking myself questions like who, then, is allowed to be angry? Who is allowed to become undignified when they find themselves attacked? I was fortunate to come of age when the internet was still unformed; the story was similar, but we coded our lives ourselves, in HTML. So what must it be like now, to have all that access—to be faced on an infinite scroll with all that seemingly unresolvable hatred—and still be subjected to the same old rules; still told, unequivocally, to smile?

It isn’t fair that some men can scream and still become Supreme Court Justice. Or that saying your life matters—not matters more, just matters—is something with which people feel they can argue. Or that a targeted stream of vitriol can drive you away from something you love. How can anyone come of age under those conditions? How can they accept who they are, much less open themselves to the trials and triumphs of love?

Of course, I say all this and then add, by the way, that this book is a rom-com. In Twelfth Knight, two nemeses with nothing in common fall head-over-heels in love, because of course they do. There are antics (obviously)—there is misunderstanding (classic)—there is buoyancy, silliness, and wit (I promise)—there is Comic-Con, fantasy media, and an unabashed framework of gaming tropes (for fun!). But beneath the banter and the Shakespeare and the comedy of errors that ensues, I hope you will also find that there is reassurance, maybe even a promise, whether you’re coming of age or not: that your anger is righteous and just. That the endurance with which you face the world is admirable. That your vulnerability, your longing to be wanted just as you are, is worthy. The landing for this love story is a soft one, and I did that not to lie to you, but because even with all the impossibility and the anger, it still felt the most honest.

Because sometimes, in spite of everything, we find a way together to make the happy endings true.

xx Alexene

We’re bringing the book club to life ✨

Next week, join Into the Blue author Emma Brodie and Reese’s Book Club alum Clare Leslie Hall (New York Times bestselling author of Broken Country) for a live discussion on Substack!

We’re diving into our April pick and opening up the floor to all subscribers for a community Q&A. This is your chance to ask your burning questions in real-time. 👀

🗓️ Thursday, April 30
⏰ 9:00 AM PT / 12:00 PM ET
📍 Live on Substack

Tap the link in our bio or head to https://reesesbookclub.substack.com/ to RSVP and join the conversation
We did not see this story going there 👀

Have you started reading Into the Blue by @emma.c.brodie yet?
Book lovers en route… Story Walks are coming to a city near you! #AppleBooksPartner 

We’re teaming up with @AppleBooks to host walking audiobook club events that inspire movement, connection, and community. Ready to press play on a new experience? Let’s stroll with a story and make some new friends, book lovers!

Nashville, TN - May 9, 2026
Chicago, IL - June 13, 2026
San Diego, CA - August 1, 2026

Your next chapter is about to begin! Visit our link in bio to register and learn more.
Happy Earth Day 🌎✨ We’re taking our stories outside today. 

Where’s your favorite outdoor reading spot?
Where stories live — and where we love to read them 💛📚 #ad

We teamed up with @westelm to bring a little extra cozy to the Hello Sunshine office, creating bookish spaces made for flipping pages, marking passages, and getting lost in a good story. ✨

From sunlit corners to comfy couches, every spot is designed to celebrate the joy of reading (and maybe finding your next favorite pick 😉).

Which space would you curl up in first? 👇